It is a stock argument from our domestic leftists that the Europeans do it better than we do. While their standard of living is a bit lower than ours and their economic growth anemic, the standard held up is one of "social justice". In Europe the economy might not be as vibrant as ours, but the socialist safety net ensures that no one really suffers deprivation. Additionally, it is held that the Europeans have gotten past the narrow nationalistic mode of thinking which is really just racism in disguise. Unfortunately, as with all leftwing arguments, reality is very far away from theory:
LE BLANC-MESNIL, France - Young rioters set fire to at least 50 vehicles in an eighth night of unrest in the impoverished suburbs of northeastern Paris as exasperated local officials criticized politicking by national leaders.
Rioting erupted again late Thursday despite hopes that festivities ending the fasting month of Ramadan would calm rioters, many of them Muslims of North African origin protesting against race bias they say keeps them in second-class status.
Note all that - riots, racism, poverty...all of the sins normally ascribed by the left to the United States, but they are all happening in France. And it doesn't look like the French government is going to gain control of the situation easily. What has happened here? Quite simple - this is what you get when you build a socialist society. It is inevitible that when you make equality your paramount goal that you will not only not get equality (an impossibility), but you will also get poverty and despair as your efforts to force people into boxes comes a cropper. People - real, flesh and blood human beings - are not built for socialist utopias. We are built to look after ourselves, to strive for higher things and to be protected in our God-given rights...we are not made for a mindless bureaucrat telling us that we can't work more than 35 hours a week because we'd earn "too much" if we did so.
Eventually, France will gain control of these riots - my bet is by means of financial bribes to self-selected "leaders" of the rioters. But the fundamental problem will remain. As long as France - and the rest of the European Union - remains wedded to an ideal of equality rather than liberty, France - and Europe - will continue their downward slide into irrelevance and, eventually, barbarism. Let the lesson of France be held firmly in the American mind - let us work diligently to prevent those who would duplicate France's ideals here in the United States from gaining power.
Posted by Mark Noonan at November 4, 2005 04:47 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.blogsforbush.com/mt/president.cgi/5911
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference France Undone:
Political Satire Fake News - The Nose On Your Face linked with Paris Riots Enter 8th Night, Rioters Earn Accolades
The morning after an unprecedented eighth night of rioting in a northeastern Paris suburb, an exhausted but proud group of young Muslim participants awoke to discover that they had been named honorary United States sports fans. This news clearly buoyed
[Read More]
Tracked on November 4, 2005 07:25 AM
T. Longren linked with French Muslim Riots Continue
“Paris Muslim Riots” may not apply much longer as rioting is now taking place in at least 20 suburbs of Paris. Why all the rioting you ask? A couple Muslim teenagers were electrocuted when they entered a power substation and got fried. ...
[Read More]
Tracked on November 4, 2005 10:07 AM
Alamo Nation linked with Update from Surrenderland
Riots abound as French ordered to bathe by the U.N.
[Read More]
Tracked on November 4, 2005 10:45 AM
Down deep in Texas: The View from Waco linked with Paris Burning?
As the rioting continues in Northeastern Paris, the French seem to be totally paralyzed by what is going on, and the MSM still refuses to be honest about who is causing it. In the following stories, the emphasis is mine.
[Read More]
Tracked on November 4, 2005 06:44 PM
Comments
The question remains: why did these people find attraction in leaving North Africa and moving to France in the first place, if it wasn't the promise of socialism's free lunch? The French and the rest of Europe are just beginning to learn chapter one economics the hard way. I suspect there are a lot more lessons ahead, that they brought upon themselves, and it won't be limited to ecomnomics!
Posted by: DL at November 4, 2005 05:36 AM
In addtion to the riots, racism, and poverty, the dirty little secret about Europe in general and France and Germany in particular is that anti-sematism is alive an well, growing like a cancer just under the skin of society. This always comes as a surprise to my liberal friends in the US, its hard for them to believe.
European support for the Palestinians is nothing more than anti-semetic in origin.
I have been shocked several times to have it surface in polite dinner conversations among well bred, well educated citizens of both France and Germany.
But I suppose that after the attacks on Michelle Malkin and Mr. Steele in Maryland, I should have realized that for liberals, racist, religious and gender hypocrisy is OK as long as your target is not a socialist.
Posted by: phnxbmed at November 4, 2005 08:29 AM
History does repeat itself, particularly with the French "aristocrats". The current group of French leftist, have never forgotten how to deal with the poor. They are still using the Marie Antoinette line of "So let them eat cake!". The French never learn. They again show their true colors with a lack of sensitivity to their own underprevileged. Their revolution by the Paris poor in the late 1700's started the heads rolling when the cries of the poor where ignored by King Louis and Queen Marie, who were the government of the time.
The current leader of the left, French "King Cher-Iraqi" has asked for calm(sic) and his henchman "Prince DeVelop-pain" cries out with regal indignation that "Law and order will be restored!"
After fattening their "royal" personal coffers with chummy ally Sadam's gold, they again ignore the same people Louis did, and may very well pay the same consequences, at least politically. We can only hope.
Posted by: Larry Finley at November 4, 2005 08:43 AM
Eight nights of riots and counting, and now they've spread to other cities!
Schadenfreude, anyone?
Posted by: Macker at November 4, 2005 08:51 AM
Clearly France has a very deep immigration / social integration problem. But it is not a question of either equality or liberty - it is the balance struck for both by a good, responsible government that counts.
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, — That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it . . ."
While rioting is almost always counter productive in that it hands the power and cover to criminals, we have to remember that one person's valuable cargo is another's harbor teapot protest!
Posted by: Karl Ruser at November 4, 2005 10:00 AM
Way to fight the stereotype that that foreign politics never is the neocons strong suit. France has had a rightwing majority for the last couple of years, the last socialist president was Mitterand. The riots, I can assure you, is not the result of the LACK of Reaganomics and evil, but that the social welfare is not being extended to already disenfranchised groups in french society.
Yes, racism exists in Europe and there is no standard solution for that one. There needs to be a sensible debate and I commend France for at least trying to diffuse the religious sidetracks by upholding secularism with its' ban on headscarfs. Church and state should be seperated. What we don't need is LePen and Haider taking their cues from bombastic pundits like Limbaugh or O'Reilly.
This comment is also a very neat way of illuminating that "compassion" side of conservatism to thoose fools who thought that this was just cynical branding efforts from the Bushies.
Posted by: theswede at November 4, 2005 10:10 AM
"France has had a rightwing majority for the last couple of years, the last socialist president was Mitterand"
Thats the trouble with socialists and left wing idealogues, they think they are centrists.
LePen represents the mainstream right of center in France as much as David Duke does here in the US.
Minister of the Interior, Internal Security and Local Freedoms, Nicholas Sarkozy is the head of the right of center movement.
The problems faced by France are well expressed above by DL. The illegal immigrants and many of the legal immigrants from Africa and the Middle East came specifically for the free lunch of socialism.
And riots and hatred are how they repay their hosts. But theswedes solution is to increase social benefits...not solve the problem by growing the economy and increasing job opportunities. Get a clue...Capital flees taxation, and no amount of wishing it weren't so will stop it. Restrictive legistaltion only speeds up the flight of capital and thus jobs.
11% unemployment and negative GDP growth!
Old Europe is crumbling under the weight of socialism, this is only a manifestation of that reality.
Posted by: phnxbmed at November 4, 2005 11:12 AM
To borrow a phrase from our liberal friends, "Burn baby burn!"
Posted by: Rich at November 4, 2005 11:57 AM
The MSM and the world are finally seeing that Europe is being transformed into Eurabia by mass Muslim immigration into Europe. These Muslim immigrants come to Europe by the tens of millions and refuse to integrate into their host European societies. Instead, they want the societies of the host countries to become more Islamic. High Muslim birthrates mean that the European Muslim populations are growing exponentially, while the non-Muslim European populations are decreasing due to low birthrates. These horrible riots by Muslim youths are only the beginning. Not only will France see more and more of these riots, so will the rest of Europe. Islam is a violent death-cult and these Islamic rioters are demonstrating that violence in spades. France and Europe had better wake up before it's too late.
Posted by: Freedom1 at November 4, 2005 06:19 PM
Hugh Hewitt had an excellent interview with Mark Steyn about the Riots in Paris.
Mark Steyn said there is a Euroarabian Civil War currently happening in the suburbs of France.
Mark Steyn-Euroarabian Civil War in France
(excertps):"HH: And so, you're not going to Paris anytime soon?"
MS: I'm actually thinking of going to Paris. I went to one of these suburbs that's currently ablaze three years ago. And what was interesting to me is I had to bribe a taxi driver a considerable amount of money just to take me out there. They're miserable places. But what was interesting to me is that after that, I then flew on to the Middle East, and I was in Yemen, and a couple of other places. And what was interesting to me was that I found more menace in the suburbs of Paris than I did in some pretty scary places in the Middle East. I mean, there is a real...this, I think, is the start of a long Eurabian civil war we're witnessing here.
HH: Now that's a pretty provocative statement. Let's begin by...describe these for us. Are they like the Moscow or the Leningrad or the St. Petersberg tenements that stretch on and on?
MS: Well, actually, I would say they're more miserable than that...
HH: Wow.
MS: ...because a lot of them are like concrete bunkers. They have very strange things there...these public buildings that you have to have a kind of security card to get into. So, you'll be going to see someone, and you'll be frantically sticking this kind of key card in the door, while you're standing outside on this very exposed sidewalk. They're places where people who are not Muslim feel very ill at ease. They're places where the writ of the French state does not run. The police don't police there. They basically figure if you go there, you're on your own. You're taking your own chances there. I mean, I don't think Americans understand quite the degree of alienation of some of these groups...."
[...]
HH: "...This is what...what option do they have if these riots continue, though? They can't appease people who won't be appeased.
MS: No, they can't. And essentially, you're dealing with communities that are totally isolated from the mainstream of French life. Where all kinds of practices that wouldn't be tolerated, that are not officially tolerated by French law, such as polygamy, for example. Polygamy is openly practiced in these...in les Banlieux, as they call these suburbs, these Muslim quarters of Paris. I mean, we're talking about five miles from the Elysee Palace. Five miles from where Jacques Chirac sits. And you finally got...you know, we kept hearing all this stuff ever since September 11th, you know, the Muslim street is going to explode in anger. Well, it finally did, and it was in Paris, not in the Middle East."
Posted by: Freedom1 at November 4, 2005 07:35 PM
theswede,
France, regardless of government, is governed under socialist principles...it is ingrained in French law and custom, and the inevitible result of socialism is the riots we see in Paris today.
Socialims is built upon hatred, envy, isolation and despair...it is no wonder that the most hated, envious, isolated and despairing have taken to riots...and it is also no wonder that the French government doesn't give the rioters what they deserve: hot lead and cold steel. Socialism also breeds moral weakness...the inability to protect the weak against the strong because it is easier to bribe the strong. The people who are suffering under the riots are the poorest people in France...and the French government is blithely allowing it to happen.
Posted by: Mark Noonan at November 4, 2005 08:43 PM
Freedom1 wrote:
"Islam is a violent death-cult and these Islamic rioters are demonstrating that violence in spades. France and Europe had better wake up before it's too late."
Umm... it IS too late. I knew 10 years ago that France was heading to this. When Muslim groups succeeded in restricting "public" pools to one gender-only at a time, THAT was (a sign of) the beginning of the end.
Posted by: Podunkct at November 5, 2005 08:32 AM
Podunkct: "Umm... it IS too late."
Perhaps, but I like to think positively! With God, all things are possible-even the survival of Europe.
Posted by: Freedom1 at November 5, 2005 06:24 PM
"When Muslim groups succeeded in restricting "public" pools to one gender-only at a time, THAT was (a sign of) the beginning of the end."
What about when they restricted wearing veils in schools? Was that a step in the right or the wrong direction?
Posted by: shortz at November 6, 2005 12:20 PM
boy you are really hung up on the veils. Anything to excuse their behavior. Are you muslim shortz? Or do you just fall lock step into the defense of anything that reinforces the Bush Doctrine.
Posted by: bearmanUSMC at November 7, 2005 12:23 AM
Or do you just fall lock step into the defense of anything that reinforces the Bush Doctrine
That didn't quite come out the way it should have! oops. You defend the cruel nature of the situation with excuses, because it reinforces the Bush Doctrine, and we can't be having that now can we.
Posted by: bearmanUSMC at November 7, 2005 12:27 AM
Shortz wrote:
"What about when they restricted wearing veils in schools? Was that a step in the right or the wrong direction?"
Apples and oranges. Banning of headscarfs *or other religious paraphanalia* was an attempt to diffuse growing religous based tensions, and whether you agree or disagree, was enacted by a legitimate national government. Restricting pool use by gender was imposed by religious groups and was, unfortunately, acquiesced to at the time by a timid local government.
Posted by: Podunkct at November 7, 2005 08:15 PM
Post a comment

The question remains: why did these people find attraction in leaving North Africa and moving to France in the first place, if it wasn't the promise of socialism's free lunch? The French and the rest of Europe are just beginning to learn chapter one economics the hard way. I suspect there are a lot more lessons ahead, that they brought upon themselves, and it won't be limited to ecomnomics!
In addtion to the riots, racism, and poverty, the dirty little secret about Europe in general and France and Germany in particular is that anti-sematism is alive an well, growing like a cancer just under the skin of society. This always comes as a surprise to my liberal friends in the US, its hard for them to believe.
European support for the Palestinians is nothing more than anti-semetic in origin.
I have been shocked several times to have it surface in polite dinner conversations among well bred, well educated citizens of both France and Germany.
But I suppose that after the attacks on Michelle Malkin and Mr. Steele in Maryland, I should have realized that for liberals, racist, religious and gender hypocrisy is OK as long as your target is not a socialist.
History does repeat itself, particularly with the French "aristocrats". The current group of French leftist, have never forgotten how to deal with the poor. They are still using the Marie Antoinette line of "So let them eat cake!". The French never learn. They again show their true colors with a lack of sensitivity to their own underprevileged. Their revolution by the Paris poor in the late 1700's started the heads rolling when the cries of the poor where ignored by King Louis and Queen Marie, who were the government of the time.
The current leader of the left, French "King Cher-Iraqi" has asked for calm(sic) and his henchman "Prince DeVelop-pain" cries out with regal indignation that "Law and order will be restored!"
After fattening their "royal" personal coffers with chummy ally Sadam's gold, they again ignore the same people Louis did, and may very well pay the same consequences, at least politically. We can only hope.
Eight nights of riots and counting, and now they've spread to other cities!
Schadenfreude, anyone?
Clearly France has a very deep immigration / social integration problem. But it is not a question of either equality or liberty - it is the balance struck for both by a good, responsible government that counts.
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, — That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it . . ."
While rioting is almost always counter productive in that it hands the power and cover to criminals, we have to remember that one person's valuable cargo is another's harbor teapot protest!
Way to fight the stereotype that that foreign politics never is the neocons strong suit. France has had a rightwing majority for the last couple of years, the last socialist president was Mitterand. The riots, I can assure you, is not the result of the LACK of Reaganomics and evil, but that the social welfare is not being extended to already disenfranchised groups in french society.
Yes, racism exists in Europe and there is no standard solution for that one. There needs to be a sensible debate and I commend France for at least trying to diffuse the religious sidetracks by upholding secularism with its' ban on headscarfs. Church and state should be seperated. What we don't need is LePen and Haider taking their cues from bombastic pundits like Limbaugh or O'Reilly.
This comment is also a very neat way of illuminating that "compassion" side of conservatism to thoose fools who thought that this was just cynical branding efforts from the Bushies.
"France has had a rightwing majority for the last couple of years, the last socialist president was Mitterand"
Thats the trouble with socialists and left wing idealogues, they think they are centrists.
LePen represents the mainstream right of center in France as much as David Duke does here in the US.
Minister of the Interior, Internal Security and Local Freedoms, Nicholas Sarkozy is the head of the right of center movement.
The problems faced by France are well expressed above by DL. The illegal immigrants and many of the legal immigrants from Africa and the Middle East came specifically for the free lunch of socialism.
And riots and hatred are how they repay their hosts. But theswedes solution is to increase social benefits...not solve the problem by growing the economy and increasing job opportunities. Get a clue...Capital flees taxation, and no amount of wishing it weren't so will stop it. Restrictive legistaltion only speeds up the flight of capital and thus jobs.
11% unemployment and negative GDP growth!
Old Europe is crumbling under the weight of socialism, this is only a manifestation of that reality.
To borrow a phrase from our liberal friends, "Burn baby burn!"
The MSM and the world are finally seeing that Europe is being transformed into Eurabia by mass Muslim immigration into Europe. These Muslim immigrants come to Europe by the tens of millions and refuse to integrate into their host European societies. Instead, they want the societies of the host countries to become more Islamic. High Muslim birthrates mean that the European Muslim populations are growing exponentially, while the non-Muslim European populations are decreasing due to low birthrates. These horrible riots by Muslim youths are only the beginning. Not only will France see more and more of these riots, so will the rest of Europe. Islam is a violent death-cult and these Islamic rioters are demonstrating that violence in spades. France and Europe had better wake up before it's too late.
Hugh Hewitt had an excellent interview with Mark Steyn about the Riots in Paris.
Mark Steyn said there is a Euroarabian Civil War currently happening in the suburbs of France.
Mark Steyn-Euroarabian Civil War in France
(excertps):"HH: And so, you're not going to Paris anytime soon?"
MS: I'm actually thinking of going to Paris. I went to one of these suburbs that's currently ablaze three years ago. And what was interesting to me is I had to bribe a taxi driver a considerable amount of money just to take me out there. They're miserable places. But what was interesting to me is that after that, I then flew on to the Middle East, and I was in Yemen, and a couple of other places. And what was interesting to me was that I found more menace in the suburbs of Paris than I did in some pretty scary places in the Middle East. I mean, there is a real...this, I think, is the start of a long Eurabian civil war we're witnessing here.
HH: Now that's a pretty provocative statement. Let's begin by...describe these for us. Are they like the Moscow or the Leningrad or the St. Petersberg tenements that stretch on and on?
MS: Well, actually, I would say they're more miserable than that...
HH: Wow.
MS: ...because a lot of them are like concrete bunkers. They have very strange things there...these public buildings that you have to have a kind of security card to get into. So, you'll be going to see someone, and you'll be frantically sticking this kind of key card in the door, while you're standing outside on this very exposed sidewalk. They're places where people who are not Muslim feel very ill at ease. They're places where the writ of the French state does not run. The police don't police there. They basically figure if you go there, you're on your own. You're taking your own chances there. I mean, I don't think Americans understand quite the degree of alienation of some of these groups...."
[...]
HH: "...This is what...what option do they have if these riots continue, though? They can't appease people who won't be appeased.
MS: No, they can't. And essentially, you're dealing with communities that are totally isolated from the mainstream of French life. Where all kinds of practices that wouldn't be tolerated, that are not officially tolerated by French law, such as polygamy, for example. Polygamy is openly practiced in these...in les Banlieux, as they call these suburbs, these Muslim quarters of Paris. I mean, we're talking about five miles from the Elysee Palace. Five miles from where Jacques Chirac sits. And you finally got...you know, we kept hearing all this stuff ever since September 11th, you know, the Muslim street is going to explode in anger. Well, it finally did, and it was in Paris, not in the Middle East."
theswede,
France, regardless of government, is governed under socialist principles...it is ingrained in French law and custom, and the inevitible result of socialism is the riots we see in Paris today.
Socialims is built upon hatred, envy, isolation and despair...it is no wonder that the most hated, envious, isolated and despairing have taken to riots...and it is also no wonder that the French government doesn't give the rioters what they deserve: hot lead and cold steel. Socialism also breeds moral weakness...the inability to protect the weak against the strong because it is easier to bribe the strong. The people who are suffering under the riots are the poorest people in France...and the French government is blithely allowing it to happen.
Freedom1 wrote:
"Islam is a violent death-cult and these Islamic rioters are demonstrating that violence in spades. France and Europe had better wake up before it's too late."
Umm... it IS too late. I knew 10 years ago that France was heading to this. When Muslim groups succeeded in restricting "public" pools to one gender-only at a time, THAT was (a sign of) the beginning of the end.
Podunkct: "Umm... it IS too late."
Perhaps, but I like to think positively! With God, all things are possible-even the survival of Europe.
"When Muslim groups succeeded in restricting "public" pools to one gender-only at a time, THAT was (a sign of) the beginning of the end."
What about when they restricted wearing veils in schools? Was that a step in the right or the wrong direction?
boy you are really hung up on the veils. Anything to excuse their behavior. Are you muslim shortz? Or do you just fall lock step into the defense of anything that reinforces the Bush Doctrine.
Or do you just fall lock step into the defense of anything that reinforces the Bush Doctrine
That didn't quite come out the way it should have! oops. You defend the cruel nature of the situation with excuses, because it reinforces the Bush Doctrine, and we can't be having that now can we.
Shortz wrote:
"What about when they restricted wearing veils in schools? Was that a step in the right or the wrong direction?"
Apples and oranges. Banning of headscarfs *or other religious paraphanalia* was an attempt to diffuse growing religous based tensions, and whether you agree or disagree, was enacted by a legitimate national government. Restricting pool use by gender was imposed by religious groups and was, unfortunately, acquiesced to at the time by a timid local government.